- A leading gynaecologist has recently claimed that female
politicians are using testosterone implants to try to match their male
counterparts in assertiveness and competitiveness.
-
- Malcolm Whitehead, a Harley Street doctor, said he had
prescribed the hormone for a number of women who wanted to "beef up"
their image in the macho world of politics. He commented: "I have
prescribed testosterone implants for female politicians in Westminster
who want to compete better with their male colleagues in committee meetings
and parliamentary debates. They claim the hormone boosts their assertiveness
and makes them feel more powerful."
-
- His extraordinary claim - recently published in the New
Statesman magazine - was greeted with disbelief in Westminster - but, then
again, which female MP was going to publicly admit to trying testosterone?
-
- Patricia Hewitt, the Trade and Industry Secretary, said:
"MPs are far more likely to succeed if they use rational arguments
rather than hormonal-fuelled rhetoric." Margaret Beckett, the Environment,
Food and Rural Affairs Secretary, also denied using the implants, saying:
"Women don't have to be like men to be successful." And Conservative
Julie Kirkbride added: "I can't believe Margaret Thatcher would have
resorted to this type of thing, and she got to the top in a man's world."
-
- But Mr Whitehead, who runs a trust offering advice to
menopausal women, maintained he is increasingly being approached by women
MPs wanting testosterone implants. The hormone - which is said to fuel
a man's sex drive - is produced in small amounts by women - up to ten times
lower levels.
-
- However, as women age those levels can dip, just as the
female hormones more usually associated with the menopause do. Testosterone
and related hormones in women are produced from the same organs where more
traditional female hormones originate - the ovaries and the adrenal glands,
which sit just above the kidneys. The lower testosterone levels of the
menopause are associated with causing women to lose interest in sex, have
lower energy levels and, in some cases, reduces their confidence and mood.
-
- Testosterone implants are meant to solve that problem.
The treatment involves embedding a small pellet under the skin, which releases
a fixed testosterone dose into the bloodstream over a six-month period.
-
- Critics claim this has dangers, but Mr Whitehead dismissed
that suggestion, saying: "As long as they stay within the normal hormonal
range, there is nothing to worry about. All the talk of deepening voices
and beard growth is complete nonsense."
-
- Testosterone can't as yet be taken orally, but can be
taken as a skin patch, a chemical that dissolves under the tongue, or as
an injection.
-
- The most sophisticated medical view now of hormone replacement
therapy for women in the menopause is that it should probably include a
touch of testosterone as well to assist with mood and sex drive.
-
- But a key controversy is that, unlike the situation in
men, we still lack enough data about how normal testosterone levels vary
in women throughout their life span or even through the monthly menstrual
cycle. So it's difficult to know from a blood test what would constitute
abnormally low levels and what would therefore need topping up from treatment.
-
- Given the definite advantages to women in terms of mood
and drive on taking testosterone, this leads some doctors to suggest it
should be tried without any hard evidence that the woman is suffering from
an actual testosterone deficiency.
-
- But Labour's Bridget Prentice - who was recently promoted
to the whip's office - said she had not heard of colleagues using the implants.
"Women are more than able to compete without taking steps like this,"
she added.
-
- However the medical scientists investigating the role
of testosterone in women don't share this apparent scepticism among high-powered
women. They believe that testosterone plays an important role in maintaining
mental and physical functions of healthy women.
-
- A recent study in the Netherlands found that taking testosterone
dissolved under the tongue markedly improved normal women's sex drive and
arousal.
-
- Another study by Dr Valerie Grant at the University of
Auckland, New Zealand, found that how dominant you were as a woman was
strongly linked to how high your testosterone levels were. A previous similar
study had found higher testosterone levels in professional and managerial
women compared to housewives and clerical workers.
-
- Dr Helen Bateup, a neuroendocrinologist, and colleagues
at the Rockefeller University in New York recently examined how competing
in rugby games effected the testosterone levels in women. In an intriguing
and unique experiment they performed blood tests on a nationally recognised
college women's rugby team in order to investigate how women's hormones
change in anticipation of and response to aggressive striving.
-
- Men characteristically experience a testosterone increase
in anticipation of competition. This pre-competition rise is likely to
make the individual more willing to take risks, improve psychomotor function
like hand-eye co-ordination and increase cognitive performance as these
are all the positive effects of testosterone on the body and brain. For
a few hours following competition, testosterone is high in sports winners
relative to losers and this rise in testosterone following a win is associated
with positive mood.
-
- Studies show that these changes also occur in non-physical
competition such as chess matches. This suggests testosterone is so useful
in bringing about changes that help improve competitiveness that physical
competition is not all that is needed to produce a testosterone surge.
-
- This has the intriguing implication that we could all
benefit from testosterone even if we are not contemplating a physical competitive
challenge like a sport, but perhaps an intellectual contest, just as MPs
do in the aggressive atmosphere of parliament.
-
- Indeed, active participation in the competition is not
necessarily required either to influence testosterone. Testosterone levels
increase among spectators watching their favourite sports teams win and
decrease for the fans of the losing teams. These findings suggest that
just being in parliament, taking part in the charged atmosphere and watching
the competition, is enough to raise your testosterone levels.
-
- But if just watching a game you are involved in as an
active fan can significantly raise your testosterone levels then maybe
you don't need to go to a Harley Street doctor to obtain supplementation
- perhaps it is possible to boost your levels more naturally.
-
- Strategies that would do this include taking part in
competitive sport. Indeed, just regular physical exercise will boost testosterone
and women who exercise regularly have significantly higher testosterone
levels than those who don't.
-
- But maybe the historical huge contrast in testosterone
levels between men and women had an evolutionary basis which it might be
dangerous to mess with. Women's response to challenges may be more defensive
in nature than men's - the female approach has been termed a "tend
and befriend" strategy to differentiate it from the "fight or
flight" response attributed to men and which their higher testosterone
levels probably helps produce.
-
- However, it's important not to forget the nickname given
to testosterone by endocrinologists is the "one night stand"
hormone as it increases sex drive and risk taking. So it's thought to underpin
the much greater male propensity to seek unattached sex compared to women.
-
- If female politicians really are taking testosterone
or are having their levels boosted by being in the competitive atmosphere
of parliament, could these hormonal changes have wider political implications?
Are we more likely in the future to see female MPs getting caught up in
the kind of sex scandals that have so characterised male politicians?
-
- If this is the case it might mean that testosterone causes
women politicians to lose at least one clear advantage female MPs historically
had over the men ... at least their families could trust them more.
-
- - Dr Raj Persaud is consultant psychiatrist at the Maudsley
Hospital in South London and the author of From the Edge of the Couch,
published by Bantam Press, £12.99
-
- ©2003 scotsman.com
-
- http://www.thescotsman.co.uk/health.cfm?id=813172003
|