- NEW YORK -- White
House officials have undermined their own government scientists' research
into climate change to play down the impact of global warming, an investigation
by The Observer can reveal.
-
- The disclosure will anger environment campaigners who
claim that efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions are being sabotaged
because of President George W. Bush's links to the oil industry.
-
- Emails and internal government documents obtained by
The Observer show that officials have sought to edit or remove research
warning that the problem is serious. They have enlisted the help of conservative
lobby groups funded by the oil industry to attack US government scientists
if they produce work seen as accepting too readily that pollution is an
issue.
-
- Central to the revelations of double dealing is the discovery
of an email sent to Phil Cooney, chief of staff at the White House Council
on Environmental Quality, by Myron Ebell, a director of the Competitive
Enterprise Institute (CEI). The CEI is an ultra-conservative lobby group
that has received more than $1 million in donations since 1998 from the
oil giant Exxon, which sells Esso petrol in Britain.
-
- The email, dated 3 June 2002, reveals how White House
officials wanted the CEI's help to play down the impact of a report last
summer by the government's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), in which
the US admitted for the first time that humans are contributing to global
warming. 'Thanks for calling and asking for our help,' Ebell tells Cooney.
-
- The email discusses possible tactics for playing down
the report and getting rid of EPA officials, including its then head, Christine
Whitman. 'It seems to me that the folks at the EPA are the obvious fall
guys and we would only hope that the fall guy (or gal) should be as high
up as possible,' Ebell wrote in the email. 'Perhaps tomorrow we will call
for Whitman to be fired,' he added.
-
- The CEI is suing another government climate research
body that produced evidence for global warming. The revelation of the email's
contents has prompted demands for an investigation to see if the White
House and CEI are co-ordinating the legal attack.
-
- 'This email indicates a secret initiative by the administration
to invite and orchestrate a lawsuit against itself seeking to discredit
an official US government report on global warming dangers,' said Richard
Blumenthal, attorney general of Connecticut, who has written to the White
House asking for an inquiry.
-
- The allegation was denied by White House officials and
the CEI. 'It is absurd. We do not have a sweetheart relationship with the
White House,' said Chris Horner, a lawyer and senior fellow of CEI.
-
- However, environmentalists say the email fits a pattern
of collusion between the Bush administration and conservative groups funded
by the oil industry, who lobby against efforts to control carbon dioxide
emissions, the main cause of global warming.
-
- When Bush first came to power he withdrew the US - the
world's biggest source of greenhouse gases - from the Kyoto treaty, which
requires nations to limit their emissions.
-
- Both Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney are former oil
executives; National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice was a director of
the oil firm Chevron, and Commerce Secretary Donald Evans once headed an
oil and gas exploration company.
-
- 'It all fits together,' said Kert Davies of Greenpeace.
'It shows that there is an effort to undermine good science. It all just
smells like the oil industry. They are doing everything to allow the US
to remain the world's biggest polluter.'
-
- Other confidential documents obtained by The Observer
detail White House efforts to suppress research that shows the world's
climate is warming. A four-page internal EPA memo reveals that Bush's staff
insisted on major amendments to the climate change section of an environmental
survey of the US, published last June. One alteration indicated 'that no
further changes may be made'.
-
- The memo discusses ways of dealing with the White House
editing, and warns that the section 'no longer accurately represents scientific
consensus on climate change'.
-
- Some of the changes include deleting a summary that stated:
'Climate change has global consequences for human health and the environment.'
Sections on the ecological effects of global warming and its impact on
human health were removed. So were several sentences calling for further
research on climate change.
-
- A temperature record covering 1,000 years was also deleted,
prompting the EPA memo to note: 'Emphasis is given to a recent, limited
analysis [which] supports the administration's favoured message.'
-
- White House officials added numerous qualifying words
such as 'potentially' and 'may', leading the EPA to complain: 'Uncertainty
is inserted where there is essentially none.'
-
- The paper then analyses what the EPA should do about
the amendments and whether they should be published at all. The options
range from accepting the alterations to trying to discuss them with the
White House.
-
- When the report was finally published, however, the EPA
had removed the entire global warming section to avoid including information
that was not scientifically credible.
-
- Former EPA climate policy adviser Jeremy Symons said
morale at the agency had been devastated by the administration's tactics.
He painted a picture of scientists afraid to conduct research for fear
of angering their White House paymasters. 'They do good research,' he said.
'But they feel that they have a boss who does not want them to do it. And
if they do it right, then they will get hit or their work will be buried.'
-
- Symons left the EPA in April 2001 and now works for the
National Wildlife Federation as head of its climate change programme. The
Bush administration's attitude was clear from the beginning, he said, and
a lot of people were working to ensure that the President did nothing to
address global warming.
-
- - Additional reporting by Jason Rodrigues
-
- Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited
2003
-
- http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,12271,1046388,00.html
|