Rense.com



Flu Shot Order Bugs
Paramedics Almost Half
Face Suspensions If They
Don't Get Injected By
December 20
Su-ann Levy
The Toronto Sun
12-17-00
 
"It's got mercury as a preservative. It's got
aluminum in it," he said.
 
 
Nearly half of the city's 754 paramedics could be off the job over the busy Christmas period if they don't get a flu shot by next Wednesday.
 
According to internal Toronto Emergency Medical Services memos obtained by the Sun, paramedics have been told they must provide proof they've been given a flu shot - or a note from their doctor saying they're medically "contraindicated" (e.g. allergic to the shot) - by December 20.
 
"Failure to provide such documentation may result in non-disciplinary suspension of employment," says a Nov. 7 memo to Toronto paramedics.
 
But only about 400 paramedics have been inoculated - or have coughed up a doctor's note - to date, Ron Kelusky, general manager of Toronto Ambulance confirmed yesterday.
 
Several paramedics I spoke to over the past few days are up in arms over being forced to take the shot and are prepared to be disciplined to make their point.
 
Ray Ellis, a 47-year-old Level 1 paramedic, says he's against the shot because he doesn't feel it protects him against the flu or from being a carrier. Besides, he says, why should he take an injection about which there are many questions?
 
"It's got mercury as a preservative. It's got aluminum in it," he said.
 
"I've already notified my supervisor I will take a one-day suspension," he added, despite a doctor's appointment on December 19 when he'll probably get a note.
 
Another North York-area Level 1 paramedic, who asked not to be named, said he's already got his doctor's note.
 
"They're violating our rights to choose... we shouldn't be forced to have something injected into our bodies."
 
"I'm not going to get it done... it should be a personal choice," says Roberta Scott, a Level 3 paramedic, who's fully prepared to be sent home without pay Wednesday night when she reports to work. "There's a group of us who are going to stand firm."
 
The Ministry of Health handed down the mandatory flu shot edict to all Ontario paramedics back in May, says Kelusky. (Under the Ambulance Act, paramedics must be immunized against a whole slew of diseases.)
 
TO PREVENT TRANSMISSION
 
"It's to prevent the transmission of disease to vulnerable populations because they're moving around... this flu does kill old people," Kelusky offers as the reason for the edict.
 
"I'm kind of the ham in the sandwich here," he said. "I understand their concerns about being forced to do it."
 
Asked whether those who refuse the shot will be suspended, he responded: "There is an issue of compliance... I am obligated to comply with the Ambulance Act."
 
CUPE Local 416 president Brian Cochrane said, following a meeting with their lawyer yesterday, the union is filing a grievance with the city today and is contemplating a challenge under the Charter of Rights.
 
Cochrane says it would be "pretty stupid" of the city to force paramedics off the job at this busy time of year, should they not comply wit the flu shot order.
 
What's upset paramedics most about the edict is that they seem to have been singled out.
 
No other health care provider I contacted this week makes mandatory flu shots a condition of employment.
 
NURSES CAN REFUSE
 
Melanie Pottins of the Ontario Nurses' Association says they worked a compromise into their collective agreements. It says hospital nurses have the right to refuse a flu shot, but may be placed on an unpaid leave of absence during an outbreak.
 
Sandra Pitters, general manager of the city's Homes for the Aged division, says the 2,800 employees in their 10 homes are "strongly encouraged," but not forced, to get a flu shot. But she says they've been clear that if there is an outbreak, those who don't have shots will be sent home, possibly without pay.
 
At Mt. Sinai Hospital, flu shots are not mandatory but recommended and some 70% of staff have been inoculated so far, says spokesperson David Davenport.
 
"Where it doesn't make sense is when I hand off my patient to the triage nurse at the hospital and she hasn't had her flu shot," says Ellis.
 
Asked why paramedics have been singled out, Ministry of Health spokesperson David Jensen said it's because there are so few paramedics - only 5,000 - in the province.
 
"It's a lot easier to find backup for doctors and nurses in hospitals should they get the flu... not so with paramedics."
 
Meanwhile, Kelusky isn't worried - just yet. He suspects there will be a rash of shot-takers just before the deadline.
 
"I'm going to do everything to show I'm complying with the Act, but I'm not about to shut the service down," he said.



 
 
MainPage
http://www.rense.com
 
 
 
This Site Served by TheHostPros