Four and a half years after
crisis conditions erupted, nothing's been done to resolve them. The
smartest guys around haven't fixed things.
On June 14, rumors circulated about coordinated central bank intervention.
European banks are especially troubled. Recapitalizing them hasn't worked.
Expecting more of the same to accomplish what hasn't so far worked is
another way of defining failure.
Along with talk of more stimulus, Egan-Jones Ratings, an independent
NRSRO (Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organization), downgraded
French sovereign debt from A- to BBB+ with a negative outlook. Doing
so shows core European weakness.
Dutch banks were also downgraded. So were Spanish ones and sovereign
Spanish and Cyprus debt. Both countries approach junk status.
Germany shows weakness. Its 10-year sovereign debt jumped over 30 basis
points from recent lows. It's troubled by having to fund more bailouts
or face euro dissolution issues. It's also pressured by having to shore
up the ECB in case it's threatened.
The average Eurozone country has a 500% debt/GDP ratio. Expects more
defaults, write-downs, and frantic steps to shore up sovereign debt.
Spanish bonds touched 7% before settling slightly lower. Liquidity isn't
the problem. Markets are awash with it. At issue is sovereign and banking
Multiple intervention rounds solved nothing. Neither will more of the
same. Structural problems remain unresolved. More time alone is bought.
It doesn't come cheap. The price is greater debt, higher service costs,
and eventual crisis conditions too grave to fix.
Bad policies don't change basic economic fundamentals. Non-performing
European bank loans are increasing. Italy may be the next Spain. Its
sovereign yields top 6%. More on what's bad there getting worse below.
Economic growth forecasts are increasing. Europe's recession deepens.
Next year looks worse, not better. Synchronized global slowing is occurring
with ammunition running out to address it.
Five years ago, OECD countries sovereign debt/GDP ratios were 70%. Today
it's 106% and rising. Governments are less able to stimulate growth.
Failing to assures greater trouble. Rising debt + higher service costs
+ falling growth = eventual house of cards collapse.
Germany is Europe's backstop. Bailouts are wearing thin. Over two-thirds
of Germans want Greece out of the Eurozone. They're tired of paying
for its problems.
People thought the ECB would be Europe's Bundesbank proxy. They were
also told Maastricht had no bailout provision. In fact, "risk mutualization"
was part of the treaty. Two trillion euros were created to deal with
crisis conditions. German taxpayers bore one-third of the cost. At issue
is for how much longer?
If it's unable or balks, what then? On the eve of Greece's election,
it's unclear who'll win. Will a third run-off be needed? Does it matter
Whatever the outcome, Greece is bankrupt. Its debt is impossible to
repay. Increasing it makes things worse. Ordinary people face harder
than ever hard times, not relief no matter who's president or controls
They have three choices - starve, leave, or rebel.
Greece must choose between austerity or default and restructuring, whether
in or outside the Eurozone. Leaving is no minor matter. Global economies
will manage. Adjustments will be made. They'll take time.
Lorenzo Bini-Smaghi calls Grexit a political and economic nightmare.
Leaving the euro, he believes, requires also exiting the EU. Greece
could also be sued. He sees a lose-lose situation. Either choice assures
Citigroup economist Michael Saunders believes Grexit is virtually certain.
Perhaps by New Year's day 2013 it'll come.
He "assume(s) that Greece will leave EMU in early 2013, followed by
a sharp currency devaluation" and economic contraction. He also thinks
contagion will be limited, June 17 election results will be inconclusive,
and the Troika will ride to the rescue.
Leaving may be another Lehman moment. Expect painful readjustments,
geopolitical tensions, market turmoil, trade frictions, greater crisis,
and eventual stability provided counterproductive policies are reversed.
Nothing so far suggests it. Austerity exacerbates hard times. Jobs are
destroyed, not created. People are running out of money and patience.
Continental unraveling is increasing.
Suicides are rising. Garbage isn't collected. Other public services
are eroding. Vital ones like healthcare and education are affected.
Greece faces collapse. Spain is close behind.
Public heath crises loom. Serious illnesses aren't treated. Lifesaving
drugs are in short supply. Hospitals aren't operating properly. An Athens
one said basic items are running out. They include cotton wool, catheters,
gloves and examining table paper covering.
Greece was ordered to cut healthcare spending from 10 - 6% of GDP. Imagine
any country reducing medical spending by 40%. Imagine desperate people
needing care unable to get it. Imagine disease and death tolls rising.
Imagine public anger exploding.
Italy potentially is Europe's biggest problem. If it goes, so does the
continent. It's troubled. It's too big to bail out. No one's sure how
much times remains to shore up its economy and other EU ones. George
Soros and IMF head Christine Lagarde say less than three months.
Italian debt auctions aren't encouraging. One year paper went for 3.972%.
A month ago it was 2.34%. Longer dated debt yields are rising. Italy
is where Spain was weeks ago.
Appointed Prime Minister Mario (three card) Monte's tax increases are
backfiring. Value-added receipts are down. Economic conditions are troubled.
Harvard Professor Alberto Alesina said:
"This government has raised taxes too much. It would be much, much better
to lower spending."
How that will help when stimulus is needed he didn't explain. Economic
deterioration is increasing. Q I results show 0.8% contraction after
slipping 0.7% in Q IV, 2011.
Italy is Europe's third biggest economy after Germany and France.
It's in serious trouble. It's problems are severe. Its sovereign debt
burden is huge. It's currently at around 120% of GDP and rising. It's
about two trillion euros. When economic growth is needed, it's declining.
Its industrial production dropped for nearly two years. It's about one-fourth
lower than when 2008 crisis conditions erupted.
Unemployment is growing. It approaches 10%. For youths it exceeds 30%.
Business confidence is down. Consumer confidence is at record lows.
According to Bloomberg, Spain and Italy "appealed to European policy
makers to step up their response to the financial crisis after a 100
billion euro ($125 billion) lifeline for Spanish banks failed to calm
Societe Generale chief European economist James Nixon calls Italy the
"next domino" to fall. "The southern European economies are effectively
in free-fall and market appetite for southern European debt is rapidly
drying up. I canít see anything to turn that dynamic around," he said.
At the same time, Germany's parliament hasn't approved the European
Stability Mechanism (ESM) bailout fund. Internal wrangling continues.
ESM is supposed to be operating by July 1. German approval is required.
Chancellor Angela Merkel wants two issues passed together. Opposition
Social Democrats (SPD) and Greens want a financial transaction tax,
as well as measures to stimulate growth.
A June 21 meeting is planned. Unresolved issues separate both sides.
Some SPD members threaten to delay the bill until fall. Eurozone countries
have until yearend to ratify it.
Parliamentary elections are over a year away, but political posturing
Germany also prioritizes fiscal/political union ahead of resolving other
problems. It wants European countries bound under one size fits all
rules it controls. They include austerity and debt reduction. These
measures haven't worked and won't now.
With Germany calling the shots, Gordian knot diplomacy remains unresolved.
Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at email@example.com.
His new book is titled "How Wall Street Fleeces America: Privatized
Banking, Government Collusion and Class War"
Visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com and listen to cutting-edge
discussions with distinguished guests on the Progressive Radio News
Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays at 10AM US Central time
and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs are archived for easy