SIGHTINGS


 
Harvesting Babies In
Latin America - Most
Doctors Don't Even Know
Source: Channel Two (FOX) San Francisco
5-15-99
 
 
CALI, Colombia -- Many victims of strokes, heart attacks and blood clots in their lungs are alive today thanks to a drug called abbokinase.
 
In the past 20 years, millions of patients have been given the life-saving drug, which re-opens clogged blood vessels and prevents further blood clots.
 
But what most doctors do not know is that the key ingredient of the drug, also known as urokinase, comes from the kidneys of babies who die at birth.
 
One source, one city, one hospital Even more disturbing is that the baby kidneys used to make the drug come from only one hospital in one city in the whole world: Cali, Colombia.
 
The vast majority of Cali's people are very poor, but the city is also home to notorious cocaine kingpins. Rebel guerrillas and tropical diseases are constant hazards.
 
A KTVU exclusive investigation sought to discover why the con-manufacturers of the drug " Abbott Laboratories, based near Chicago, and BioWhittaker, based in Maryland " use dead babies from just one hospital in an impoverished Third World city.
 
Some doctors are beginning to question the source of this "miracle drug" and the ethical problems associated with it.
 
"I do not understand why it is necessary to go to South America to get this tissue," said Dr. Sidney Wolfe, a health researcher formerly with the National Institutes of Health. Wolfe currently is the health research director for the consumer watchdog organization Public Citizen.
 
Daniel Callahan, one of the most respected medical ethicists in the U.S., said he was deeply disturbed after learning the source of abbokinase.
 
"The first reaction is a vague sense of repugnance that this goes on at all," Callahan said. "It seems to me a very strange and disturbing situation."
 
Practice not illegal, but is there a need? The practice of using baby tissue to make drugs is not illegal. But medical ethicists say there is no need to use human tissue. At least five other drug companies make synthetic drugs that do the same thing, for about the same price.
 
It's a lucrative market " Abbott Labs sells about $250 million worth of abbokinase every year. But even doctors at De Valle Hospital in Cali, for many years the source of the kidney cells used to make abbokinase, were not aware of Abbott Labs' connection.
 
Dr. Antonio Madrid, a lead doctor in the hospital's neo-natal intensive care unit, says it is almost impossible to imagine removing kidneys from dead children.
 
"It is part of the culture here," he told KTVU. "The parents don't want the bodies interfered with. They don't want the bodies touched."
 
'A criminal act' Cali's Catholic Archbishop Isaias Duarte calls the practice a "criminal act, an abomination if it is true."
 
The hidden source of abbokinase came to light about two months ago, after the FDA issued an alert warning that the drug may infect patients with potentially deadly diseases such as hepatitis or even AIDS.
 
That's because the kidney cells used to make the drug come from a population where tropical diseases and hepatitis are very common, and those diseases can be passed to users of the drug.
 
So why Colombia, and not the U.S. or another Western nation? It could be that the infant mortality rate is more than three times that of the U.S.
 
"It would certainly be easier to get neo-natal kidney tissue in a country that has a higher mortality rate," said Wolfe. "But one of the reasons the mortality rate is higher is because of more infectious diseases which itself should be a reason for not getting kidneys from that part of the world."
 
 
KTVU's Randy Shandobil talks about investigating abbokinase Non-javascript browsers
 
Evidence of the high mortality rate is on display in the streets surrounding the hospital " there are more than a dozen funeral homes, prominently displaying baby caskets.
 
Of the average 30 births each day at the hospital, about 10 percent " two or three babies a day " are lost. Part of the reason for the high rate of deaths is a major shortage of equipment, such as incubators and even beds.





SIGHTINGS HOMEPAGE