SIGHTINGS


 
Space Station Faces Space
Debris Danger - Boeing
Said $986 Million Over Budget
By Mark Prigg
www.sunday-times.co.uk
5-10-99
 
 
NASA is to waive its safety requirements for the International Space Station (ISS) in a bid to get it in orbit earlier.
 
The Russian-built service module, which serves as the first crew's living compartment, has failed Nasa's tests for surviving collisions with orbiting space junk. In a bid to keep the station on schedule Nasa has waived the requirements and is now planning to send collision shields to the module once it is in orbit.
 
However, according to Allen Li, an associate director with the US General Accounting Office who last week reviewed Nasa's budget with the Senate, the shields will not be ready for three years, meaning the first crew members will have to sleep in an unprotected module.
 
"The current plan is for Nasa to issue a waiver at the time of launch, and then correct the problem when the module is in orbit," Li told a Senate panel that oversees Nasa's activities.
 
Li also revealed that although Russia is working with Nasa to get the shielding in place, Nasa could end up footing the bill. "This is another area where we may have to pick up the slack for Russia, not just in terms of paying for the hardware, but also the EVAs [space walks] we would have to schedule to install them."
 
When Russia began its involvement in the station, all the ISS partners decided there was only a 19% chance of the station being hit by debris, and planned protection accordingly. However, as more modules were added, this rose to a 24% chance. Once the Russian Service Module is added to the ISS, there will not be enough shielding on the station to protect it.
 
According to Nasa's tests, if the service module were struck and depressurised, it would fail to work. It would have to be evacuated immediately
 
The shielding planned for the modules would help slow down debris, which could hit the station at about 75,000mph. Rather than stopping the debris dead, it will be vapourised as it passes through the shield, causing little or no damage when it finally hits the station. The shields will be mounted on arms attached to the outside of the module during a series of space walks. Shields are also likely to be added to the Zarya module already orbiting earth, as it also fails to meet Nasa's space-debris requirements.
 
As well as building extra shields for the module, Nasa and Russia are also beginning to plan for possible repairs should the module ever be damaged.
 
According to Li, Nasa is to go ahead with the launch of the module despite the safety lapses. "Nasa believes the module adds capabilities to the station that would otherwise be unavailable, and thinks it is a worthwhile risk to go ahead as planned," says Li.
 
According to Jim Oberg, a consultant who has advised the Senate on space-station issues, the move is simply Russia's way of cutting corners to get the service module in orbit.
 
He says: "Russia has been running its Mir space station for a long time with no space-debris problems. However, Mir orbits the earth at a lower altitude than the ISS. Where the ISS is, the space debris is much thicker and poses more of a risk. The ISS will also be in orbit for longer than Mir, and Nasa is most worried about the long-term effects."
 
Oberg believes Russia is cutting corners to save money. "This is really just another way for Russia to save time and money. They have also failed to upgrade the oxygen system that caught fire on Mir and will form part of the ISS - something Nasa is not happy about," says Oberg.
 
According to Dan Goldin, head of Nasa, the space agency is doing all it can to get added protection for the service module in place sooner, but he says American laws are conservative in the area of space debris, so the risks for ISS crew will not be great.
 
Joe Rothenberg, Nasa's associate administrator for space flight, says that without the additional shielding, the service module has the same level of protection as Mir, which has been in orbit since 1986 without any space-debris accidents.
 
"Russia has far greater experience than us, and they have assured us there is no problem," says Rothenberg. However, Nasa claims Russia is keen to install the shielding to adhere to Nasa's rules.
 
It has also been revealed that it is not just Russia that is facing financial problems - Boeing, the prime American contractor for the station is $986m over budget. The company claims the cost is due mainly to expensive software development for the ISS's controlling computers.





SIGHTINGS HOMEPAGE